Design Discussion: Rogue Poisons

Open discussion about OctoWow.
Kingmaedis
Posts: 7
Forum Reputation: +0 / -0

Design Discussion: Rogue Poisons

Post#1 » Thu Nov 12, 2026 6:21 pm

The changes to Rogue poisons have introduced an unnecessary level of frustration to PvE gameplay, particularly in dungeons and raids where enemy types and immunities frequently change.

The fundamental issue isn't necessarily the damage output of poisons, but rather the way their effectiveness is arbitrarily restricted by enemy classification.

Currently, Rogues are frequently forced to alternate between Instant/Deadly Poison and Dissolvent/Corrosive Poison, despite these poisons serving essentially the same purpose: dealing additional damage.

This is particularly frustrating in Molten Core, Black Morass, Dire Maul East, Scholomance, and Blackwing Lair.

This doesn't create meaningful gameplay decisions, but rather unnecessary maintenance.

I believe the better solution is to completely rethink what Dissolvent and Corrosive Poison are supposed to accomplish.

Rather than introducing two additional damage poisons that compete with Instant and Deadly Poison, we should redesign the system around three principles:

1. A Rogue should be able to maintain a viable damage setup throughout an entire dungeon or raid without constantly reapplying poisons.

2. Different poisons should provide genuinely different mechanical benefits rather than being interchangeable damage effects with different immunities.

3. PvP balancing should not require sacrificing PvE quality of life.

-----

Now as to what exactly that re-design should look like - I will leave that to the community and developers. Some brainstorming ideas include: raidwide physical damage amplifiers (leaning into a version of support Rogue) or something similar.

What do you guys think?
+1 / -0

Doaksie
Posts: 141
Forum Reputation: +4 / -1
Contact:

Re: Design Discussion: Rogue Poisons

Post#2 » Thu Nov 12, 2026 6:58 pm

I would say even from a PvP perspective, the Turtle-era changes to dissolvent and corrosive were pretty damaging, as rogues essentially lost the option to use two types of poisons in BGs and wPvP.
+1 / -0

Tyranny
Posts: 33
Forum Reputation: +0 / -1

Re: Design Discussion: Rogue Poisons

Post#3 » Fri Nov 13, 2026 6:51 pm

Doaksie wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 6:58 pm I would say even from a PvP perspective, the Turtle-era changes to dissolvent and corrosive were pretty damaging, as rogues essentially lost the option to use two types of poisons in BGs and wPvP.
Instant poison is literally better than disolv in pvp and PVE (unless they're immune ofc).

But yeah I agree disolv should work on ALL enemies in PVE. Just a dumb change making some dungeons/raids miserable.
+1 / -0

Kingmaedis
Posts: 7
Forum Reputation: +0 / -0

Re: Design Discussion: Rogue Poisons

Post#4 » Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:27 pm

But yeah I agree disolv should work on ALL enemies in PVE. Just a dumb change making some dungeons/raids miserable.
Honestly they could easily do two HUGE QOL improvements:

1) Make dissolv apply to PVE (and essentially function as a better instant poison in every aspect)

2) Change poison-crafting reagent vendors to sell items in stacks of five instead of individually. This would eliminate the need to click hundreds of times just to purchase enough materials to craft poisons.
+1 / -0

Tyranny
Posts: 33
Forum Reputation: +0 / -1

Re: Design Discussion: Rogue Poisons

Post#5 » Sat Nov 14, 2026 1:39 am

Kingmaedis wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:27 pm
But yeah I agree disolv should work on ALL enemies in PVE. Just a dumb change making some dungeons/raids miserable.
Honestly they could easily do two HUGE QOL improvements:

1) Make dissolv apply to PVE (and essentially function as a better instant poison in every aspect)

2) Change poison-crafting reagent vendors to sell items in stacks of five instead of individually. This would eliminate the need to click hundreds of times just to purchase enough materials to craft poisons.
There's an addon for 2 haha. Google BuyPoison turtle wow. But yeah without that addon its a real chore and your clicking finger will start hurting real quick :lol:
+1 / -0

Xiriah
Posts: 6
Forum Reputation: +1 / -0

Re: Design Discussion: Rogue Poisons

Post#6 » Sat Nov 14, 2026 8:54 am

I would agree that the poison swaping feels very clunky. Overall turtle seemed to want to make stuff easier on the player, for example soulshard stacking, so the way poisons work currently seems weird. Some kind of change to the poisons would be in order for sure.
+1 / -0

Cutt
Posts: 12
Forum Reputation: +0 / -0

Re: Design Discussion: Rogue Poisons

Post#7 » Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:41 pm

Remove enemy type restrictions from instant and dissolvent poisons. Easy fix.
+1 / -0

Cuaited
Posts: 18
Forum Reputation: +0 / -0

Re: Design Discussion: Rogue Poisons

Post#8 » Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:49 pm

I’d like to bring up a different point regarding poisons. I’ve mentioned this in the suggestion forums as well. Either remove the charges entirely and keep the 30-minute time limit, or increase the number of charges.
+1 / -0

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Aliencat1878 and 1 guest