Page 2 of 3
Re: Poll: Cooldown on switching between Alliance and Horde characters on Y'Shaarj?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 3:15 am
by Cope12
Acidburn1 wrote: Sun Nov 15, 2026 5:21 pm
Bro has the reading comprehension of a wet shoe. Nobody is crying about getting ganked—the whole thread is about losers relogging onto enemy alts to /who stalk people across three zones and whisper them because their egos are made of glass.
"Leave the area" doesn't work when the guy is literally using an opposite-faction spy to see what zone you moved to, genius. If you need a cross-faction /who crutch just to find targets in world PvP, you're dogshit at the game. Keep copy-pasting "go N'Zoth" like an NPC though, really shows you have two brain cells fighting for third place.
sounds like you're just bad at the game tbh
Re: Poll: Cooldown on switching between Alliance and Horde characters on Y'Shaarj?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 6:44 am
by Wubc
I find being able to track members of the opposing faction through /who incredibly lame... The whole system is basically just used to find the specific people you wish to gank and not the intended use case of finding friendly players.
It's been like this forever naturally and some consider it just a part of the game, but personally it's something I could absolutely do without.
Re: Poll: Cooldown on switching between Alliance and Horde characters on Y'Shaarj?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:43 am
by Cope12
Wubc wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 6:44 am
I find being able to track members of the opposing faction through /who incredibly lame... The whole system is basically just used to find the specific people you wish to gank and not the intended use case of finding
friendly players.
It's been like this forever naturally and some consider it just a part of the game, but personally it's something I could absolutely do without.
been the same way since 2005 zero reason to change it ganking was 1000x worse on telabim and these two pve brained polls were never floated once.
Re: Poll: Cooldown on switching between Alliance and Horde characters on Y'Shaarj?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 8:33 am
by Berdal
Wubc wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 6:44 am
I find being able to track members of the opposing faction through /who incredibly lame... The whole system is basically just used to find the specific people you wish to gank and not the intended use case of finding
friendly players.
It's been like this forever naturally and some consider it just a part of the game, but personally it's something I could absolutely do without.
Word.
Re: Poll: Cooldown on switching between Alliance and Horde characters on Y'Shaarj?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 8:48 am
by Wubc
Cope12 wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:43 am
been the same way since 2005 zero reason to change it ganking was 1000x worse on telabim and these two pve brained polls were never floated once.
Something having been a certain way for a long time alone is not really an argument for why it could not be improved. I am mainly indifferent as to whether it is changed or not, as I think the impact is mainly negligible, but I can certainly see the argument for doing so and the lack of a necessity to have it the way it is.
It kinda should be looked at in a vacuum. If you were to time travel back to 2005 and start from scratch, would you do it a different way to avoid such issues, or keep it as-is to enable them as normal gameplay.
Re: Poll: Cooldown on switching between Alliance and Horde characters on Y'Shaarj?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:30 am
by Cope12
Wubc wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 8:48 am
Cope12 wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:43 am
been the same way since 2005 zero reason to change it ganking was 1000x worse on telabim and these two pve brained polls were never floated once.
Something having been a certain way for a long time alone is not really an argument for why it could not be improved. I am mainly indifferent as to whether it is changed or not, as I think the impact is mainly negligible, but I can certainly see the argument for doing so and the lack of a necessity to have it the way it is.
It kinda should be looked at in a vacuum. If you were to time travel back to 2005 and start from scratch, would you do it a different way to avoid such issues, or keep it as-is to enable them as normal gameplay.
a bunch of pvebots crying they're getting ganked isn't good enough reason to throw an entire tool in the trash thats been in the game since 2005 if they dont like pvp they should just leave tbh.
Re: Poll: Cooldown on switching between Alliance and Horde characters on Y'Shaarj?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:47 am
by Wubc
Cope12 wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:30 am
a bunch of pvebots crying they're getting ganked isn't good enough reason to throw an entire tool in the trash thats been in the game since 2005.
It's pretty clear at this point that this is not a good faith argument so I'm just not going to respond anymore. It is rather disingenuous to not even entertain the idea that a system being used in an unintended manner to gain information that was not originally also not meant to be available to you in order to track down specific people could be something subject to reform.
The tool was meant to find people to group with or maybe in a specific guild you wish to contact. That was the intended usage. Anything outside it is unintentional and very much subject to be questioned. Safe spots have existed for years in BGs. Here they are against the rules as they were considered to be against the intended gameplay loop.
rules wrote:
The best way to easily determine safespotting is by asking “am I intended to be able to utilize this position?”
The question: "Am I intended to know the location of any player from the opposing faction?" is just as fair to ask.
Re: Poll: Cooldown on switching between Alliance and Horde characters on Y'Shaarj?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 11:08 am
by Cope12
Wubc wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:47 am
Cope12 wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:30 am
a bunch of pvebots crying they're getting ganked isn't good enough reason to throw an entire tool in the trash thats been in the game since 2005.
It's pretty clear at this point that this is not a good faith argument so I'm just not going to respond anymore. It is rather disingenuous to not even entertain the idea that a system being used in an unintended manner to gain information that was not originally also not meant to be available to you in order to track down specific people could be something subject to reform.
hows it bad faith i listed the dumb reason shadow decided to make two chatgpt polls without the poll correctly calling it dumb ideas because we're on a pvp server if he doesnt wanna get pvped dont play on pvp server or instead of taking up space on the forums for bad ideas call 2 friends and kill the guy ganking him final note if it was unintended for the use its being used i dont think wow would still have the exact same function as we have right now so another bad argument. call some friends leave area logout.
Re: Poll: Cooldown on switching between Alliance and Horde characters on Y'Shaarj?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 1:15 pm
by Rfdtv
Octosum wrote: Sun Nov 15, 2026 6:15 am
Should Y'Shaarj have a cooldown when switching between characters of opposite factions?
no, this is gay.
Re: Poll: Cooldown on switching between Alliance and Horde characters on Y'Shaarj?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 3:57 pm
by Acidburn1
Cope12 wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 11:08 am
Wubc wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:47 am
Cope12 wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:30 am
a bunch of pvebots crying they're getting ganked isn't good enough reason to throw an entire tool in the trash thats been in the game since 2005.
It's pretty clear at this point that this is not a good faith argument so I'm just not going to respond anymore. It is rather disingenuous to not even entertain the idea that a system being used in an unintended manner to gain information that was not originally also not meant to be available to you in order to track down specific people could be something subject to reform.
hows it bad faith i listed the dumb reason shadow decided to make two chatgpt polls without the poll correctly calling it dumb ideas because we're on a pvp server if he doesnt wanna get pvped dont play on pvp server or instead of taking up space on the forums for bad ideas call 2 friends and kill the guy ganking him final note if it was unintended for the use its being used i dont think wow would still have the exact same function as we have right now so another bad argument. call some friends leave area logout.
Congratulations, you just proved you have zero idea what you’re talking about—and you did it on your "final note."
Blizzard literally banned creating characters on both factions on the same PvP server in 2005 for this exact reason: so losers couldn't log onto an enemy alt to /who stalk and harass people. They kept that restriction in place for nearly five years until Patch 3.2 in late 2009, and they brought the exact same faction lock right back for Classic PvP servers in 2019.
The only reason /who wasn't restricted cross-faction in 2005 is because you physically couldn't make an enemy character on the same PvP realm to abuse it with. Calling it an "intended 2005 feature" when Blizzard went out of their way to make it impossible in 2005 is honestly impressive levels of clueless.
You spent four posts screaming "pvebots" and "go N'Zoth" only to end with an argument that proves the exact opposite of what you think it does. Sit down before you embarrass yourself any further.