Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:05 pm
As a certified paladin enjoyer with thousands of hours playing the class on turtle and now octo, playing one in pvp and playing against one in pvp on my warlock, I have to agree with Nezu here.
Paladins have their counters, warlocks were mentioned as one, hunters with viper sting are another, and even warriors/rogue can effectively "hamstring" a paladin, making it so they can only use holy shock to heal or get interrupted.
Eemo's observations of the class are absolutely correct, the issue is in the proposed solutions.
1. "Adjust the interaction or nerf the mana gain from seal of wisdom / judge of wisdom"
This wouldn't work for a few reasons. I spent 3k hours on turtle as a prot paladin, just in PvE. Tanked in every iteration of the class (cc1, cc2), seal/judgement of wisdom isn't enough mana gain to be entirely comfortable. We already get some mana back from blocking, but I'd like to highlight that the traditional holy PvP spec, also has these talents that give mana back on a block. Just as a final note on this point; personally I never use seal/judgement of wisdom in PvP, as I don't feel the need.
2. "Adjust the interaction or nerf blessed strike talents so the unhealthy cycle of crusader strike into instant burst heal for every 6 seconds can stop."
This is a really bad solution. It effectively kills the class identity in a PvE meta already dominated by priest and druid healers. A paladin cannot compete with a priest's "Prayer of healing" in terms of output, this is well reflected in the logs. Paladins are melee healers, and if I'm honest, I haven't been tempted by WoWForever because their iteration of hpala is so bad. This would absolutely effect PvE healing, to a massive degree.
Same deal with the mana cost of spells here, you can't really increase them a significant amount to effect PvP without nerfing PvE heavily, the class identity of a hpala is that they are a very efficient melee healer, these changes would effectively strip that back.
3. "Increase the CD of Divine shield from 5 to 8 minutes or more"
I'm not sure this would achieve much in practice, I think disabling bubble completely in PvP might be the play, I think that would even the playing field a little more than 3 more minutes on a cd. Lay on hands is already disabled in Arena, so Bubble should be the next step imo.
4. "Increase forbearance to 2 minutes instead of 1"
This is a good change that won't really effect PvE too much, but I don't see it fixing the main issue either. It could be paired with bubble being forbidden in arenas/bgs to put the class back amongst the others.
A few final points,
I'm sure we'll have some people in here hoping for the nerfs to PvP, and even PvE to see Paladins "suffer". This is all well and good, part of the banter, but what you need to remember is, it's Paladins now. If Paladins and shamans get a sizeable nerf, it'll be another class on top that people complain about, and eventually it'll wrap around to your class. Some people take another class being better than theirs as a personal attack.
I think removing bubble from PvP will make it a lot more digestible to play against, nobody likes having their work, in this case, killing a paladin, invalidated by the fact they can go completely immune for 12 seconds and heal to full. It is my opinion as a paladin main, but also a warlock with plenty of pvp experience on Octo, that the other strong aspects of a hpala can be countered, just like any other class.
I'm curious if there are any other holy paladins that can chime in on this. You have to be very careful to nerf them in PvP, but leave them untouched in PvE.
Paladins have their counters, warlocks were mentioned as one, hunters with viper sting are another, and even warriors/rogue can effectively "hamstring" a paladin, making it so they can only use holy shock to heal or get interrupted.
Eemo's observations of the class are absolutely correct, the issue is in the proposed solutions.
1. "Adjust the interaction or nerf the mana gain from seal of wisdom / judge of wisdom"
This wouldn't work for a few reasons. I spent 3k hours on turtle as a prot paladin, just in PvE. Tanked in every iteration of the class (cc1, cc2), seal/judgement of wisdom isn't enough mana gain to be entirely comfortable. We already get some mana back from blocking, but I'd like to highlight that the traditional holy PvP spec, also has these talents that give mana back on a block. Just as a final note on this point; personally I never use seal/judgement of wisdom in PvP, as I don't feel the need.
2. "Adjust the interaction or nerf blessed strike talents so the unhealthy cycle of crusader strike into instant burst heal for every 6 seconds can stop."
This is a really bad solution. It effectively kills the class identity in a PvE meta already dominated by priest and druid healers. A paladin cannot compete with a priest's "Prayer of healing" in terms of output, this is well reflected in the logs. Paladins are melee healers, and if I'm honest, I haven't been tempted by WoWForever because their iteration of hpala is so bad. This would absolutely effect PvE healing, to a massive degree.
Same deal with the mana cost of spells here, you can't really increase them a significant amount to effect PvP without nerfing PvE heavily, the class identity of a hpala is that they are a very efficient melee healer, these changes would effectively strip that back.
3. "Increase the CD of Divine shield from 5 to 8 minutes or more"
I'm not sure this would achieve much in practice, I think disabling bubble completely in PvP might be the play, I think that would even the playing field a little more than 3 more minutes on a cd. Lay on hands is already disabled in Arena, so Bubble should be the next step imo.
4. "Increase forbearance to 2 minutes instead of 1"
This is a good change that won't really effect PvE too much, but I don't see it fixing the main issue either. It could be paired with bubble being forbidden in arenas/bgs to put the class back amongst the others.
A few final points,
I'm sure we'll have some people in here hoping for the nerfs to PvP, and even PvE to see Paladins "suffer". This is all well and good, part of the banter, but what you need to remember is, it's Paladins now. If Paladins and shamans get a sizeable nerf, it'll be another class on top that people complain about, and eventually it'll wrap around to your class. Some people take another class being better than theirs as a personal attack.
I think removing bubble from PvP will make it a lot more digestible to play against, nobody likes having their work, in this case, killing a paladin, invalidated by the fact they can go completely immune for 12 seconds and heal to full. It is my opinion as a paladin main, but also a warlock with plenty of pvp experience on Octo, that the other strong aspects of a hpala can be countered, just like any other class.
I'm curious if there are any other holy paladins that can chime in on this. You have to be very careful to nerf them in PvP, but leave them untouched in PvE.