Praylorswift wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:05 pm
hello, Praylorswift/Parishealton here, double holy paladin enjoyer
if we're looking at log output we of course have to remember what phase of content we are in. Paladins do in fact have access to red dragonscale set, very powerful in phase 1, since the hot from the set can proc from holy strike (a minor aoe heal). Even with this, paladins will not top the logs. And that's a log padding tactic as the hot is not directable. This gets worse in phase 2 (current phase). As others have pointed out from the aggregates on the chronicle website, they come in third out of 4 healer classes.
This is ok. they have their topping the logs moment in later phases of content. And this is typical of the game, different classes and specs excel at different phases. If anything, I think we should give shamans more love (<3 my horde brethren).
The mana discussion is an interesting one. Mana is only "infinite" (not really but close enough) when the paladin can go into mele. A lot of people have this idea that paladin somehow just has infinite mana. There is a requirement to get mana back. and the tradeoff is not minor.
If you have to stay at range (certain fights require it), you have the worst sustain/mana pool. And two of your three main healing spells are now gone (they are mele ranged). They worked hard to force the paladin into mele and it worked, its a terrible ranged healer.
At the end of the day, none of this really matters though, there aren't really any healing mana check fights in the game right now. Are there even any in later phases of content? and in speed runs, you can't hit things for long enough to get mana back and you flask of wisdom, mana and tea like everyone else.
pve tldr: not even close to the best right now, worse at range, will get better later, mana does not matter as much, buff shamans (<3).
But enough on pve. while it is fun to discuss its not why we are here. Back to OP's topic, pvp.
I'm assuming you dont play holy paladin? I read from the thread you are a druid, i'm kinda assuming you don't play resto either?
From a game design perspective (any game), healers are op in pvp. this is why you will see games that try to take pvp seriously, or at least competitively, completely avoid healers. Games like lol will have support classes with very minor heals or regen. Healing, as a mechanic, is just overpowered. because a 3v3 or a 5v5 where one side has a healer, and the other does not, turns into a 6v3 and 10v5 in the span of a couple of gcds.
(note, there's a trick to guarantee to always have a healer on your team!).
This is why healers get prioed in pvp. And if you wish to balance healers in pvp you need to decide how their survivability will work.
If you really wanna talk mmo competitive pvp, terms that don't really go together well, there are nevertheless examples we can look at. Probably the most successful implementation was warhammer online, age of reckoning. Which was shut down and later came back as return of reckoning. There a single dps could simply not kill a healer. You would need at least two to bring one down. And the damage overall was much lower (not as bursty). The fights were much much longer (and in my personal opinion better, but this is probably also due to tanks actually having a role in pvp) than in any other mmo of such type i've ever player (and by Uther's beard there have been many).
I don't understand where this problem of "I can't kill this healer" 1v1 comes from. You can't kill a warlock 1v1 either. At least the healer can't kill you back...the warlock certainly can. The healer might be able to survive you 1v1...but he can't do anything. You could potentially argue that he can defend a point like that, but no organized bg will do that, that's a waste of a role that can have a multiplicative effect on a group of players in a fight.
This brings us to group pvp and survivability. The core of the healer balancing issue. There's a couple of ways to do survivability in pvp. The two main ways are mobility and tankiness. By far the better of the two is mobility (speed and cc negation).
Tankiness is bad. You can make a class tanky. This means it will be hard to kill in a 1v1. or even a 1v2. This doens't matter in group pvp as there will be more than two players. Tankiness is the bad kinda survivability to have. Mobility is much better. It doesn't matter how many people try to focus you, if none of them can hit you. Now you could say that the tradeoff is that if you do get caught, you die...but that's true for anyone who gets caught by a group of players.
Here is the problem. there is no skill required to have tankiness. Its easy. There is a lot of skill required for mobility.
Now lets get back to wow/twow/octowow.
Paladin has tankiness as its survivability mechanic. What is worse, its a mele healer, and that is not a place you want to be in pvp. On top of that you have NO mobility. And as we have already outlined, if you do want to stay at range instead, you're even worse (both with mana and you've given up on two of your three healing spells).
So you get a short temporary invulnerability button to compensate. It comes with a long cooldown so it cant be used in every fight. You need to decide which two or three fights in the bg you should blow it on. And to be perfectly clear. the Fight needs to be won during that bubble duration. If it is not, once it ends, you're an immobile healer in the middle of a group fight...
Resto druid is MUCH better. Mobility, cc immunity and hots. Oh my...
Absolute monster in bgs.
But lets focus on why people complain about hpalas and not resto druids, and the suggestions in your post.
paladin is the most played class on the server and its not even close. A lot of those, when they go into pvp, play holy. And healers are op in pvp.
When you see a pink wave on the other team, you're not annoyed that its full of paladins, you're annoyed that it is, most likely, full of healers. And healers are op in pvp.
I guarantee you that if druids were the most popular class, with no changes - exactly as they are right now, and every bg was versus a bunch of druids, people would make posts like these about druids too.
What is worse...its easy. Like I said there is no skill required to be tanky. There is no skill required to press bubble.
Now a resto druid is, in my opinion, a better bg healer. But it is much harder to do. You won't see many of them. And therefore you wont see posts like this about them.
But the most popular class on the server? With a super annoying (but not op, at lest in my opinion) ability? yeah, thats gonna cause posts...
The paladins main problem is that it has a super annoying ability, that requires no skill to use, is the most popular class on the server and can play heal. It's not actually op. But it will by definition be the most complained about.
I mean just look at win ratios before mixed battlegrounds...
This is why its sometimes hard to take the many posts in this thread...in the spirit of good intentions. Your suggestions are to...just remove paladin abilities? Ok, you wanna take tankiness away as its survivability mechanic. ok. and replace it with? You wanna give them mobility?
And you wanna take away the mele heals? And replace them with?
I agree that arena nerfs were required. Lay on hands is now gone, and bubble now has a shared cooldown between arenas (no longer resets). And the holy shock libram was fixed to no longer affect healing.
That being said, as per the above discussion, if you cannot in fact be descended upon by a group of players, because the amount of players is artificially limited, i.e., arenas, tankiness can be good. For example 2v2s. But there are classes that can take much better advantage of this. Have you played against rogues in 2v2s?
tldr: buff shamans