Page 1 of 1

Nerf Diminishing Returns on HKs in Alterac Valley

Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 8:53 pm
by Zvyrhol
DIMINISHING RETURNS

Diminishing returns on honor is a game-mechanic in WoW that decreases your honor gained from killing same player repeatedly. On Octo WoW every time you kill the player, you get 10% less honor from Honorable Kill (HK) on that player. This stacks up to 100%, then you get 0 honor for HK. This penalty is applied to everyone that got HK on the player.

Diminishing returns on honor was added in early version of Vanilla to prevent people from farming honor via multiboxing or by killing same people back when battlegrounds didn't exist.
It served good purpose but it also limited earning honor via killing people.


PROBLEM

Meanwhile, Alterac Valley suffers from a specific problem. If both teams are heavily focused on attacking, match is usually short, ends quickly, everyone gets good honor. However, if it becomes turtle (long match) due to big defence, the honor gained per hour for everyone is minimal or close to 0 and game is being extended. This makes current Alterac Valley inconsistent because of large fluctuations in honor gained based on if the games is turtle or not.

Turtle WoW restored 1.5 version of AV which promotes turtling and yet they forgot to fix the honor gained when turtle occurs.
Results are obvious: people are mad, frustrated and they feel they are wasting their time. Which is a shame because despite turtles being honor-wise inefficient, they are iconic part of WoW. Turtle AV is one of these few places where teams clash together in large-scale team fights.


SOLUTION

This idea is directly taken from my thread https://octowow.st/forum/viewtopic.php?t=1605 that was implemented on a local server. The solution is following:
DIMINISHING RETURNS ON HONOR
  • Limit impact of diminishing returns on honor to 50% in Alterac Valley. That means players get at least 50% of honor for honorable kill.
Now the penalty stacks up to 50% instead of 100%. For example, first kill grants 100% of HK value, second one 90%, third one 80%... Fifth HK is the limit and every next HK on the player always grants 50% of honor from HK.
Note, this works only in AV. In other battlegrounds and open world, old formula is still applied.
In practice, players will no longer suffer from earning 0 honor in turtle AV. Large PvP battles should be new source of decent honor.

This idea is good for couple of reasons:
  • Very easy to implement.
  • Enjoyers of both long and short AV games are satisfied. The former can play how they want and the latter no longer suffer from bad honor/hour rate. Currently, these 2 groups usually oppose each other because of opposing interests - tension on BG chat is guaranteed. This idea connects interest of both groups.
  • Fixes miserable honor gained in turtle.
  • This will have no impact on quick AV games as well as HKs outside Alterac Valley. In quick games, there is almost 0 HKs if everyone is attacking.
  • Code that implements this feature was tested and is at the bottom of this post.
Note that large scale battles shouldn't be better source of honor than fast games. Otherwise, objectives become pointless and brainless fighting in the Field of Strife becomes the meta.
50% is arbitrary number and should be later adjusted based on if it's too good.
I estimate 50% should be fine.

--

Here is code that worked on my core. Any dev will know what to do with this.
Formulas.h

Code: Select all

    namespace Honor
    {
        // modified to limit penalty in Alterac Valley
        inline float GetHonorGain(uint8 killerLevel, uint8 victimLevel, uint32 victimRank, uint32 totalKills = 0, uint32 groupSize = 1, bool battlegroundAV = false)
        {
            // Penalty due to level diff
            float diffLevelPenalty = XP::BaseGainLevelFactor(killerLevel, victimLevel);

            // Same unit killing penalty
            // [-PROGRESSIVE] Total kills per day cahnged in 1.12 (http://wow.gamepedia.com/Patch_1.12.0#General)
            // Honorable Kills now diminish at a rate 10% per kill rather than 25% per kill.
            float penalty = 4.0f;
            if (sWorld.GetWowPatch() >= WOW_PATCH_112 || !sWorld.getConfig(CONFIG_BOOL_ACCURATE_PVP_REWARDS))
                penalty = 10.0f;

            double sameVictimPenalty;
            if (battlegroundAV)												
	sameVictimPenalty = totalKills >= static_cast<uint32>(penalty / 2) ? 0.5 : (1.0 - ((double)totalKills / penalty)); 
            else
	sameVictimPenalty = totalKills >= static_cast<uint32>(penalty) ? 0 : 1 - totalKills / penalty;

            // Level related coefficient
            double levelCoeff;

            if (killerLevel >= 60)
                levelCoeff = 1;
            else if ((killerLevel <= 59) && (killerLevel >= 50))
                levelCoeff = 0.9545;
            else if ((killerLevel <= 49) && (killerLevel >= 40))
                levelCoeff = 0.5707;
            else if ((killerLevel <= 39) && (killerLevel >= 30))
                levelCoeff = 0.3434;
            else if ((killerLevel <= 29) && (killerLevel >= 20))
                levelCoeff = 0.2070;
            else if (killerLevel <= 19)
                levelCoeff = 0.1212;
            else
                levelCoeff = 0.1212; // Not sure

            float expFactor = 188.3f;

            // [-PROGRESSIVE] Honor gain per victim rank changed in 1.8
            // Values from http://www.wowwiki.com/Honor_system_(pre-2.0_formulas)
            if (sWorld.GetWowPatch() < WOW_PATCH_108 && sWorld.getConfig(CONFIG_BOOL_ACCURATE_PVP_REWARDS))
                expFactor = 157.4f;

            return levelCoeff * sameVictimPenalty * (expFactor * exp(0.05331 * victimRank)) * diffLevelPenalty / groupSize;
        }
    }

Re: Nerf Diminishing Returns on HKs in Alterac Valley

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 12:45 pm
by Knifewrench
No, av is almost not a bg, if anything they should reduce amount of honor AV gives.

Re: Nerf Diminishing Returns on HKs in Alterac Valley

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 2:27 pm
by Dzielkus
This is the way.