Page 1 of 2
I know what I did (and it was not last summer)
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 8:43 pm
by Dukeking
Hello,
I know what I did. But to be honest, I think the amount of gold I bought is pretty small.
Think about if you can eliminate some of the reasons for bans by simply legalizing such things and profiting from them in the process. Ultimately, people are just buying time and convenience—they’re not harming anyone. This isn’t a criticism, but I do find it a bit hypocritical to ban people for this when you yourselves are doing something illegal here. Aren’t we all pirates on a pirate island?
I also supported the server with real money because I believe in the project. I don’t regret that, even after the ban. I wish you all the best. Maybe there will be a change of heart after all. On other successful private servers, certain conveniences do work, after all.
Best regards
Re: I know what I did (and it was not last summer)
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 9:19 pm
by Ellinna3601
You are ruining other players' economy by buying gold. The gold you buy has to be farmed and injected into the economy artificially. There are many other private servers that don't ban for this at all, you may enjoy yourself there instead.
Re: I know what I did (and it was not last summer)
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 9:21 pm
by Nezu
Buying gold isn't allowed because it encourages sellers to use bots to farm, and bots are a plague on the server. The act of buying in itself also destroys the economy for everyone, gold buyers and non-buyers.
Re: I know what I did (and it was not last summer)
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 9:28 pm
by Dukeking
I understand the idea and agree on the bot side, but I find the economic reasoning a bit too narrow.
Gold earned by a player already exists within the game’s economy. When I buy that gold, it isn’t created anew—it simply changes hands.
The crucial question, therefore, is not just whether gold is injected into the economy, but how much gold is generated overall, how quickly it circulates, and what effects the additional demand has on prices and availability.
So buying gold isn’t automatically synonymous with destroying other players’ economies. To make that claim, one would have to specifically explain which economic mechanism causes this damage.
Re: I know what I did (and it was not last summer)
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 9:45 pm
by Ruin
Dukeking wrote: Wed Nov 11, 2026 9:28 pm
So buying gold isn’t automatically synonymous with destroying other players’ economies. To make that claim, one would have to specifically explain which economic mechanism causes this damage.
If you buy gold, the person selling it doesn't want to farm it by hand. They make a bot, and farm the money with bots.
Buying gold = more bots, read only this line if you're confused.
Re: I know what I did (and it was not last summer)
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 9:51 pm
by Dukeking
I understand the logic, and I'm not denying that demand for gold can create an incentive for sellers to use bots.
However, an economic incentive is not the same as proof that every gold transaction contributes to botting.
You're assuming that all gold sellers use bots and that every gold purchase directly leads to additional bot activity. That's a generalization, not an explanation of the actual economic impact.
I agree that reducing demand can be one way to combat botting. But that doesn't mean the economic argument and the botting argument are interchangeable.
My original point was about the claim that buying gold inherently destroys the economy. The fact that gold trading may encourage botting is a separate argument, and one I have already acknowledged.
We can agree that botting is harmful without pretending that gold transfers and gold generation are the same thing.
Re: I know what I did (and it was not last summer)
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:18 am
by Szrental
It has been made pretty clear that all RMT is against the rules. It's not just botting, or the economy, it's the experience. OctoWow Team has said a few times that the slow "natural" leveling experience is what they want. RMT also promotes boosting, theft and probably more.
There are several posts in this forum about bans for accounts that have been stolen and the gold from those accounts sold from RMT. Buying the gold promotes the sellers and the bans go both ways.
Dukeking wrote: Wed Nov 11, 2026 8:43 pm
This isn’t a criticism, but I do find it a bit hypocritical to ban people for this when you yourselves are doing something illegal here. Aren’t we all pirates on a pirate island?
It's not hypocritical, you getting banned for not following the rules has nothing to do with pirate island. Unless you're referring to the lawlessness aspect which would be ironic.
Re: I know what I did (and it was not last summer)
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 3:06 am
by Archer
Szrental wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:18 am
It has been made pretty clear that all RMT is against the rules. It's not just botting, or the economy, it's the experience. OctoWow Team has said a few times that the slow "natural" leveling experience is what they want. RMT also promotes boosting, theft and probably more.
There are several posts in this forum about bans for accounts that have been stolen and the gold from those accounts sold from RMT. Buying the gold promotes the sellers and the bans go both ways.
Dukeking wrote: Wed Nov 11, 2026 8:43 pm
This isn’t a criticism, but I do find it a bit hypocritical to ban people for this when you yourselves are doing something illegal here. Aren’t we all pirates on a pirate island?
It's not hypocritical, you getting banned for not following the rules has nothing to do with pirate island. Unless you're referring to the lawlessness aspect which would be ironic.
Even pirates have a code
Re: I know what I did (and it was not last summer)
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:03 am
by Wubc
I genuinely love the 0 tolerance policy and hope it is upheld ferociously.
Literally every RMT appeal thread is some variation of "I should be allowed to cheat because I paid", "Rules should not exist at all", "My cheating should be overlooked because I don't like the rules".
Keep up the good work of cleaning out the cheaters.

Re: I know what I did (and it was not last summer)
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:25 am
by Rizzlord
Dukeking wrote: Wed Nov 11, 2026 8:43 pm
Hello,
I know what I did. But to be honest, I think the amount of gold I bought is pretty small.
Think about if you can eliminate some of the reasons for bans by simply legalizing such things and profiting from them in the process. Ultimately, people are just buying time and convenience—they’re not harming anyone. This isn’t a criticism, but I do find it a bit hypocritical to ban people for this when you yourselves are doing something illegal here. Aren’t we all pirates on a pirate island?
I also supported the server with real money because I believe in the project. I don’t regret that, even after the ban. I wish you all the best. Maybe there will be a change of heart after all. On other successful private servers, certain conveniences do work, after all.
Best regards
this was a good one lol enjoyed it