Page 1 of 2
[Ban Appeal] False Positive RMT Ban
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 12:08 am
by Alan008sk
Dear OctoWoW Staff and GMs,
I am writing to respectfully appeal the recent permanent ban on my character Christmaslu (Priest, Guild: <Panda>) for the stated reason of "buying accounts." I would like to clarify that there was absolutely no Real Money Trading (RMT) or account purchasing involved in any way.
I understand why the system might have flagged the IP/hardware change on this account, so I want to be 100% transparent and honest with the GM team about what happened:
1. Guild Roster Assistance, Not Buying: The original owner of this account is a former guildmate who went AFK/quit the game. Before leaving, they entrusted the account to our Guild Master of <Panda> so the character could still help the guild when needed.
2. Filling Raid Spots: When our raid team is short on healers or caster DPS for guild runs, I log onto this character to help fill the missing spot and keep our guild raids going.
3. Zero Money Involved: No money, gold, or real-world currency was ever exchanged. This is purely a case of guildmates sharing a character to support our raid team.
I truly love playing on OctoWoW and deeply respect the server rules. Our Guild Master from <Panda> is fully aware of this situation and is willing to come forward and vouch for me to confirm that this account was entrusted to the guild and not bought.
Thank you very much for your time, understanding, and hard work in maintaining the server.
Best regards,
Character Name: Christmaslu
Guild: <Panda>
Re: [Ban Appeal] False Positive RMT Ban
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 3:50 am
by Mind123
I am the current guild leader of Panda. Two members of our guild have been banned: a priest named Christmaslu and a shaman named Sunday. I reached out to them right after I learned about this. I managed to contact the priest, but I haven’t been able to get hold of the shaman.
The priest was banned for character trading. He claims he has not committed any violations while using this character. Given the large number of recent bans, I would like to inquire whether there is a possibility of misjudgment or wrongful ban. I hope Kestrel can notice this message. It would be preferable if I could contact him privately to discuss the relevant details.
Re: [Ban Appeal] False Positive RMT Ban
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 3:54 am
by Kestrel
There are a few things here actually.
It started back on 09-01 when your character Bebemax was banned for buying gold. About a month later you did get the account with Christmaslu from a former gulidmate.
Then on 10-12 you purchased the Oathlight account, bought 800g (from the same gold seller you were just banned for buying from...) and used some of that to sell a hide of the wild and eye of shadow for 11g to yourself (on Christmaslu).
You have shown clear intent to deceive and a distinct lack of either willingness or ability to learn from your mistakes. Consider this your last warning, you may start again if you'd like to on a fresh account, but if you are caught participating in RMT again you should expect permanent bans on all future accounts that you make here. Your fresh starts have been used up as of today.
Assuming you are not able to provide some evidence of how we are mistaken in this situation. Keeping in mind that we know your former guild mate that quit the game did not give you Oathlight(the original owner(s) of the account were still very much active on the game, leveling other accounts to sell). Also unsure how you'd explain the 800g...
Re: [Ban Appeal] False Positive RMT Ban
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:28 am
by Mind123
As you mentioned, he previously had a character banned for buying gold, which violates the game’s RMT rules. However, this priest character Christmaslu originally belonged to one of our raiders. That player could no longer join our raids due to work and personal matters, so I asked the current user (the same Bebemax who was banned before) to play this priest for our guild raids.
I understand he may be flagged because of his prior RMT record and warning. But Christmaslu itself had no rule-breaking activity while this player was using it, right? If there are violations associated with this priest character, we ask that you provide clear evidence of the specific actions, Kestrel

Re: [Ban Appeal] False Positive RMT Ban
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 am
by Mind123
Also, I didn’t know about his past gold trades. I’ve told my guildies many times to avoid RMT

Re: [Ban Appeal] False Positive RMT Ban
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:39 am
by Kestrel
I believe you told your guildies to avoid RMT, and I appreciate that and actually can say without a doubt that you doing that has helped. We crunched the "per guild" numbers and your guild was not even in the top 5 for any of the stats that we looked for.
That being said the character Christmaslu is permanently banned as the owner of the account, the person making this appeal, is guilty of buying a second different account, and also buying 800g. So the source of Christmaslu is not even in question here.
Re: [Ban Appeal] False Positive RMT Ban
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 5:13 am
by Alan008sk
Dear Kestrel,
Thank you for laying out the full logs and being completely transparent with me. I want to apologize sincerely to you and the entire OctoWoW staff for not being fully honest in my initial appeal.
You are right—I did purchase the Oathlight account and the 800g on October 12th. That was a huge mistake on my part, and I take full responsibility for violating the server rules.
Regarding Christmaslu, I genuinely took over that priest solely to help our guild (<Panda>) fill our raid roster, just as Mind123 mentioned. When I transferred the Hide of the Wild and Eye of Shadow for 11g to craft gear for our guild raids, I foolishly didn't realize that doing so would taint the priest account with the RMT violation. I never intended to bring trouble to my guild or abuse the community.
I completely accept the permanent bans on those accounts and will not ask for them to be unbanned. I am truly grateful that, despite my mistakes, you are still giving me one final chance to start fresh. Whether I take a break from the game or decide to start over on a completely new account in the future, I give you my word that I will strictly follow all rules and never touch RMT again.
Thank you again for your time, fairness, and hard work in keeping OctoWoW clean.
Best regards,
Re: [Ban Appeal] False Positive RMT Ban
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 5:18 am
by Kestrel
Alan008sk wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 5:13 am
Dear Kestrel,
Thank you for laying out the full logs and being completely transparent with me. I want to apologize sincerely to you and the entire OctoWoW staff for not being fully honest in my initial appeal.
You are right—I did purchase the Oathlight account and the 800g on October 12th. That was a huge mistake on my part, and I take full responsibility for violating the server rules.
Regarding Christmaslu, I genuinely took over that priest solely to help our guild (<Panda>) fill our raid roster, just as Mind123 mentioned. When I transferred the Hide of the Wild and Eye of Shadow for 11g to craft gear for our guild raids, I foolishly didn't realize that doing so would taint the priest account with the RMT violation. I never intended to bring trouble to my guild or abuse the community.
I completely accept the permanent bans on those accounts and will not ask for them to be unbanned. I am truly grateful that, despite my mistakes, you are still giving me one final chance to start fresh. Whether I take a break from the game or decide to start over on a completely new account in the future, I give you my word that I will strictly follow all rules and never touch RMT again.
Thank you again for your time, fairness, and hard work in keeping OctoWoW clean.
Best regards,
Thank you for owning up to it and vowing to stay clean in any future attempts o7
Re: [Ban Appeal] False Positive RMT Ban
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 5:32 am
by Mind123
Your deduction is reasonable. It is understandable that you banned his previous character after discovering records of gold trading via mail logs. However, the character Christmaslu had no violations during the time he was playing it. Given the previous incident, I assigned this idle priest character to the player who formerly used Bebemax, solely to help our guild run stable raid farms.
On a side note, if I’m not mistaken, I am the first warrior on this server to reach level 60 under patch 1.17 in the Slow and Steady challenge mode. My character name is Bluechubby. We used to play on Turtle WoW. When it shut down, my raiders scattered across many other servers, searching for a suitable alternative. We were like a scattered army, and regrouping has proven incredibly difficult. We also have to deal with high latency and unstable network connections while playing.
I led my guild members to start all over again: gearing up, farming Hydraxian Waterlords reputation, clearing trash mobs in Molten Core to gather materials for fire resistance gear. We went through the Kapibara launch troubles too — the server was under attack for more than 30 hours, some players exploited bugs for in-game gains, which led to a 16-hour rollback. We also endured over a month of DDoS attacks and countless new private server launches popping up everywhere.
Still, we chose to stay. The main reason is that OctoWoW maintains a fantastic gaming environment, and we truly love this game. This would not be possible without the hard work of the GM and support team. I fully appreciate your zero-tolerance policy against RMT.
I have a suggestion. Could you take this character, reset its password, hold it for a period of time, and then return it to me? We are desperately short of raiders for our raids. Besides, the original owner of Christmaslu might come back to play OctoWoW someday. At the end of the day, I also take responsibility for this. As the guild leader, I made this hasty decision without checking the background thoroughly. If the original player comes back and finds their character banned, they will surely be heartbroken

Re: [Ban Appeal] False Positive RMT Ban
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 9:15 am
by Vichyssoise
Kestrel wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:39 am
I believe you told your guildies to avoid RMT, and I appreciate that and actually can say without a doubt that you doing that has helped. We crunched the "per guild" numbers and your guild was not even in the top 5 for any of the stats that we looked for.
That being said the character Christmaslu is permanently banned as the owner of the account, the person making this appeal, is guilty of buying a second different account, and also buying 800g. So the source of Christmaslu is not even in question here.
Is there any possibility of publicly disclosing the top five guilds for each metric? This can serve as a warning and is far more effective than banning after the fact.