Design Discussion: Rogue Poisons
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 6:21 pm
The changes to Rogue poisons have introduced an unnecessary level of frustration to PvE gameplay, particularly in dungeons and raids where enemy types and immunities frequently change.
The fundamental issue isn't necessarily the damage output of poisons, but rather the way their effectiveness is arbitrarily restricted by enemy classification.
Currently, Rogues are frequently forced to alternate between Instant/Deadly Poison and Dissolvent/Corrosive Poison, despite these poisons serving essentially the same purpose: dealing additional damage.
This is particularly frustrating in Molten Core, Black Morass, Dire Maul East, Scholomance, and Blackwing Lair.
This doesn't create meaningful gameplay decisions, but rather unnecessary maintenance.
I believe the better solution is to completely rethink what Dissolvent and Corrosive Poison are supposed to accomplish.
Rather than introducing two additional damage poisons that compete with Instant and Deadly Poison, we should redesign the system around three principles:
1. A Rogue should be able to maintain a viable damage setup throughout an entire dungeon or raid without constantly reapplying poisons.
2. Different poisons should provide genuinely different mechanical benefits rather than being interchangeable damage effects with different immunities.
3. PvP balancing should not require sacrificing PvE quality of life.
-----
Now as to what exactly that re-design should look like - I will leave that to the community and developers. Some brainstorming ideas include: raidwide physical damage amplifiers (leaning into a version of support Rogue) or something similar.
What do you guys think?
The fundamental issue isn't necessarily the damage output of poisons, but rather the way their effectiveness is arbitrarily restricted by enemy classification.
Currently, Rogues are frequently forced to alternate between Instant/Deadly Poison and Dissolvent/Corrosive Poison, despite these poisons serving essentially the same purpose: dealing additional damage.
This is particularly frustrating in Molten Core, Black Morass, Dire Maul East, Scholomance, and Blackwing Lair.
This doesn't create meaningful gameplay decisions, but rather unnecessary maintenance.
I believe the better solution is to completely rethink what Dissolvent and Corrosive Poison are supposed to accomplish.
Rather than introducing two additional damage poisons that compete with Instant and Deadly Poison, we should redesign the system around three principles:
1. A Rogue should be able to maintain a viable damage setup throughout an entire dungeon or raid without constantly reapplying poisons.
2. Different poisons should provide genuinely different mechanical benefits rather than being interchangeable damage effects with different immunities.
3. PvP balancing should not require sacrificing PvE quality of life.
-----
Now as to what exactly that re-design should look like - I will leave that to the community and developers. Some brainstorming ideas include: raidwide physical damage amplifiers (leaning into a version of support Rogue) or something similar.
What do you guys think?