Page 1 of 1

Obvious pve imbalance between prot pala and tank shaman

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:13 pm
by Tourni
So one issue has really been bothering me ever since i started playing turtle wow.
Part of the reason why we got shaman tanks is because alliance players wanted Paladins to be an effective tanking class. Ok sure i'm fine with that, but there is significant PVE imbalances, to the point where they can just solo ZG trash.
I've always wondered 'why can't my tank shaman do that?'
My turtle wow shaman on tel'abim couldn't even do that with full tier 2.5. I've tried everything, earth shield + healing stream totem, potions, crystal restore, teas, NOTHING compares to prot paladins self heal capability.

Before you argue 'my hunter can solo zg trash' or 'my warlock can do that' this is different. Your hunter and warlock are not FACE TANKING mobs, and healing through it. There needs to be better pve balance between the 2 AOE tank classes. Soloing ZG trash should be a benchmark. And if people aren't happy about shaman tanks being buffed, then paladin tanks should be nerfed appropriately.

Re: Obvious pve imbalance between prot pala and tank shaman

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:30 pm
by Zokk
Its becoming an open secret across the entire player base this class is a laughing stock tbh.

The most obvious thing is the over representation of the class isn't even the most revealing of the factors. You just have to play battlegrounds.

Im not sure the devs do though.

Re: Obvious pve imbalance between prot pala and tank shaman

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 9:20 am
by Zeryl
Shammy tanking wasn't obviously meant to keep up with pally tanking. And it never should.

See Tier sets: pally has ret, holy and prot, while shammy has ele, enh (dps) and resto.
T2.5 is flexibility minded (read "meme territory" :cry: ) since vanilla. The intention is clear. Shammy is a back-up tank, not a main one in any situation.

There is a good design and balance reason for it. Pally has a dedicated talent tree to this one activity while shammy has it half tank/half damage with several hybrid talents benefitting both. It would be unfair if shammy would be equally capable as tank but could just swap weapons and excel at that, too.
See feral druid, as results of this imbalance can be very much felt in PvP.
+ Shammy is an offensive support class, while pally defensive, so not really comparable. But it ties to the pally's capability to outsustain the mobs.

I also agree with prot pally nerfs because no one should be outsustaining ZG crocs with 50% armor pene and stuns but that's another thing.

Re: Obvious pve imbalance between prot pala and tank shaman

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:39 pm
by Eluzia
Zeryl wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 9:20 am Shammy tanking wasn't obviously meant to keep up with pally tanking. And it never should.

See Tier sets: pally has ret, holy and prot, while shammy has ele, enh (dps) and resto.
T2.5 is flexibility minded (read "meme territory" :cry: ) since vanilla. The intention is clear. Shammy is a back-up tank, not a main one in any situation.

There is a good design and balance reason for it. Pally has a dedicated talent tree to this one activity while shammy has it half tank/half damage with several hybrid talents benefitting both. It would be unfair if shammy would be equally capable as tank but could just swap weapons and excel at that, too.
See feral druid, as results of this imbalance can be very much felt in PvP.
+ Shammy is an offensive support class, while pally defensive, so not really comparable. But it ties to the pally's capability to outsustain the mobs.

I also agree with prot pally nerfs because no one should be outsustaining ZG crocs with 50% armor pene and stuns but that's another thing.

The amount of nonsense its over 9000 !:D