Page 1 of 1

Blade of eternal darkness in PVP

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 10:58 am
by Dedus
Blade of eternal darkness has a 10% proc chance (as its tooltip says) and can proc off regular spellstrikes. However, in pvp proc rate seems much lower. For example if I have 7 sources of + elemental damage on my gear the dagger should have 70% chance to proc , but it works differently depending on whether I attack a mob or a player. I've tried killing some mobs with ~5k hp and engulfing shadows (proc of BoED) has done from 600 to 900 (6-9 procs) dmg to each mob. Then I asked some players for a test and did the same. Out of ~5k of their healthpool engulfing shadows did only 74-200 dmg (1-3 procs). I understand that the dmg of the proc is reduced by pvp dampening (74 instead of 100), but the problem is that the proc chance seems MUCH lower in pvp.

Can you please check this? I think resilience might interact with the proc chance too, but I'm not quite sure

Re: Blade of eternal darkness in PVP

Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:26 pm
by Brwcht
We need to completely remove the possibility of it triggering from 1–3 additional damage points (just like all other skills and talents)— why on earth should it even work?

Stupid-buggy-abuse mechanic!

Re: Blade of eternal darkness in PVP

Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2026 11:59 pm
by Dzielkus
Brwcht wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:26 pm We need to completely remove the possibility of it triggering from 1–3 additional damage points (just like all other skills and talents)— why on earth should it even work?

Stupid-buggy-abuse mechanic!
Game obviously recognize elemental damage "on hit" (eg. +3 lightning from lizards back) as direct spellcast (casue only it tigger Engulfing Shadows). And this indeed look like abuse.
"Lost" is also abused by "necrodins" this way.

And OP wrote that he has "70%" calculated chance hit - it's not how RNG works (you have 7 separate rolls 1 to 9 to get proc not 7 to 3). Another question is does Engulfing Shadows has internal cooldown.

Re: Blade of eternal darkness in PVP

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 12:44 am
by Dapr
Dedus wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 10:58 am Blade of eternal darkness has a 10% proc chance (as its tooltip says) and can proc off regular spellstrikes. However, in pvp proc rate seems much lower. For example if I have 7 sources of + elemental damage on my gear the dagger should have 70% chance to proc , but it works differently depending on whether I attack a mob or a player. I've tried killing some mobs with ~5k hp and engulfing shadows (proc of BoED) has done from 600 to 900 (6-9 procs) dmg to each mob. Then I asked some players for a test and did the same. Out of ~5k of their healthpool engulfing shadows did only 74-200 dmg (1-3 procs). I understand that the dmg of the proc is reduced by pvp dampening (74 instead of 100), but the problem is that the proc chance seems MUCH lower in pvp.

Can you please check this? I think resilience might interact with the proc chance too, but I'm not quite sure
Exactly the same observations.

I’ve noticed that in PvP, many items with magic damage components exhibit a strange reduction in the damage they deal. For example, "Lifestealing" deals 23 damage instead of 30; "Blade of Eternal Darkness" deals 74 instead of 100; an effect that adds 4 fire damage to melee attacks deals 3; and an effect that adds 2 fire damage to melee attacks deals only 1. It appears that roughly 25% of the damage is being lost.

It’s also possible that poison damage is being reduced, though this is difficult to verify because poison damage values ​​fall within a range.

Notably, this issue does not occur in PvE; the figures in the combat logs consistently match the item descriptions.

I’ve ruled out resistances, as the combat logs explicitly indicate when a resistance occurs—whether it’s a partial or a full resist. In the logs where the damage is reduced, there is no mention of any resistance.

Furthermore, this isn't due to any damage reduction mechanics specific to Battlegrounds, as I’ve also conducted tests in World PvP.

Also, for some reason, "Blade of Eternal Darkness" procs three times less often in PvP than it does in PvE.

Could you explain what is causing this decrease in damage and procs?

Re: Blade of eternal darkness in PVP

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:19 am
by Brwcht
Dzielkus wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 11:59 pm
Brwcht wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:26 pm We need to completely remove the possibility of it triggering from 1–3 additional damage points (just like all other skills and talents)— why on earth should it even work?

Stupid-buggy-abuse mechanic!
Game obviously recognize elemental damage "on hit" (eg. +3 lightning from lizards back) as direct spellcast (casue only it tigger Engulfing Shadows). And this indeed look like abuse.
"Lost" is also abused by "necrodins" this way.

And OP wrote that he has "70%" calculated chance hit - it's not how RNG works (you have 7 separate rolls 1 to 9 to get proc not 7 to 3). Another question is does Engulfing Shadows has internal cooldown.
Of course, I understood that the author of the topic had poor math skills. I just didn’t want to focus on that.

Re: Blade of eternal darkness in PVP

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:21 am
by Brwcht
Dapr wrote: Sat Nov 21, 2026 12:44 am
Dedus wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 10:58 am Blade of eternal darkness has a 10% proc chance (as its tooltip says) and can proc off regular spellstrikes. However, in pvp proc rate seems much lower. For example if I have 7 sources of + elemental damage on my gear the dagger should have 70% chance to proc , but it works differently depending on whether I attack a mob or a player. I've tried killing some mobs with ~5k hp and engulfing shadows (proc of BoED) has done from 600 to 900 (6-9 procs) dmg to each mob. Then I asked some players for a test and did the same. Out of ~5k of their healthpool engulfing shadows did only 74-200 dmg (1-3 procs). I understand that the dmg of the proc is reduced by pvp dampening (74 instead of 100), but the problem is that the proc chance seems MUCH lower in pvp.

Can you please check this? I think resilience might interact with the proc chance too, but I'm not quite sure
Exactly the same observations.

I’ve noticed that in PvP, many items with magic damage components exhibit a strange reduction in the damage they deal. For example, "Lifestealing" deals 23 damage instead of 30; "Blade of Eternal Darkness" deals 74 instead of 100; an effect that adds 4 fire damage to melee attacks deals 3; and an effect that adds 2 fire damage to melee attacks deals only 1. It appears that roughly 25% of the damage is being lost.

It’s also possible that poison damage is being reduced, though this is difficult to verify because poison damage values ​​fall within a range.

Notably, this issue does not occur in PvE; the figures in the combat logs consistently match the item descriptions.

I’ve ruled out resistances, as the combat logs explicitly indicate when a resistance occurs—whether it’s a partial or a full resist. In the logs where the damage is reduced, there is no mention of any resistance.

Furthermore, this isn't due to any damage reduction mechanics specific to Battlegrounds, as I’ve also conducted tests in World PvP.

Also, for some reason, "Blade of Eternal Darkness" procs three times less often in PvP than it does in PvE.

Could you explain what is causing this decrease in damage and procs?
This is a global conspiracy.