Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Open discussion about OctoWow.
Reilly0
Posts: 14
Forum Reputation: +1 / -0

Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Post#11 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:05 pm

As a certified paladin enjoyer with thousands of hours playing the class on turtle and now octo, playing one in pvp and playing against one in pvp on my warlock, I have to agree with Nezu here.

Paladins have their counters, warlocks were mentioned as one, hunters with viper sting are another, and even warriors/rogue can effectively "hamstring" a paladin, making it so they can only use holy shock to heal or get interrupted.

Eemo's observations of the class are absolutely correct, the issue is in the proposed solutions.
1. "Adjust the interaction or nerf the mana gain from seal of wisdom / judge of wisdom"
This wouldn't work for a few reasons. I spent 3k hours on turtle as a prot paladin, just in PvE. Tanked in every iteration of the class (cc1, cc2), seal/judgement of wisdom isn't enough mana gain to be entirely comfortable. We already get some mana back from blocking, but I'd like to highlight that the traditional holy PvP spec, also has these talents that give mana back on a block. Just as a final note on this point; personally I never use seal/judgement of wisdom in PvP, as I don't feel the need.

2. "Adjust the interaction or nerf blessed strike talents so the unhealthy cycle of crusader strike into instant burst heal for every 6 seconds can stop."
This is a really bad solution. It effectively kills the class identity in a PvE meta already dominated by priest and druid healers. A paladin cannot compete with a priest's "Prayer of healing" in terms of output, this is well reflected in the logs. Paladins are melee healers, and if I'm honest, I haven't been tempted by WoWForever because their iteration of hpala is so bad. This would absolutely effect PvE healing, to a massive degree.
Same deal with the mana cost of spells here, you can't really increase them a significant amount to effect PvP without nerfing PvE heavily, the class identity of a hpala is that they are a very efficient melee healer, these changes would effectively strip that back.

3. "Increase the CD of Divine shield from 5 to 8 minutes or more"
I'm not sure this would achieve much in practice, I think disabling bubble completely in PvP might be the play, I think that would even the playing field a little more than 3 more minutes on a cd. Lay on hands is already disabled in Arena, so Bubble should be the next step imo.

4. "Increase forbearance to 2 minutes instead of 1"
This is a good change that won't really effect PvE too much, but I don't see it fixing the main issue either. It could be paired with bubble being forbidden in arenas/bgs to put the class back amongst the others.

A few final points,
I'm sure we'll have some people in here hoping for the nerfs to PvP, and even PvE to see Paladins "suffer". This is all well and good, part of the banter, but what you need to remember is, it's Paladins now. If Paladins and shamans get a sizeable nerf, it'll be another class on top that people complain about, and eventually it'll wrap around to your class. Some people take another class being better than theirs as a personal attack.

I think removing bubble from PvP will make it a lot more digestible to play against, nobody likes having their work, in this case, killing a paladin, invalidated by the fact they can go completely immune for 12 seconds and heal to full. It is my opinion as a paladin main, but also a warlock with plenty of pvp experience on Octo, that the other strong aspects of a hpala can be countered, just like any other class.

I'm curious if there are any other holy paladins that can chime in on this. You have to be very careful to nerf them in PvP, but leave them untouched in PvE.
+5 / -1

User avatar
Rtas
Posts: 86
Forum Reputation: +6 / -3

Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Post#12 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:46 pm

The way I see it is that some classes should just crumple against others. effectively making them tough to counter. I'd argue Shaman is actually the Horde's "hard counter" to Paladin. the problem is Turtle did kinda gimp Shaman, if their purge CD was reduced it'd probably make fighting them in BGs less of a pain. even making it like 5 secs or maybe just 3 (dunno if it HAD a cooldown originally).

Paladins are a bitch to fight, especially as a hunter. the ranged stun lets them close the gap, then (is it jdugement?) lets them stun you a 2nd time once they're in range. couple that with their blessing of freedom giving a middle finger to frost and conc shot. yeah

I also think Paladin is probably the EASIER class to play because of the toolset. you have so many means of recovering from bad situations.

I think Pallies need a toning down, but I just don't know where to start really. I'm no expert at the class and I think someone on "the inside" should be looking at the class and see what could be done to fix it, without gimping paladin into uselessness in both PvP and PvE
Reilly0 wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:05 pm
hunters with viper sting are another.
Having fought your kind, gonna say it's fairly common to see you guys just dispell it. even at my lowest rank, it costs me more I think to pop viper than it does for you to dispell it. I swear there's an addon that basically does it FOR YOU (paladins, not you specifically) before the sting even gets a tick off. Also that blessing of freedom basically fucks up the entire idea of using slows on you guys.
+3 / -0

User avatar
Ellinna3601
Posts: 47
Forum Reputation: +5 / -0

Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Post#13 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:58 pm

I agree that paladins are too strong in PvP but I don't agree with your solutions. The solution should be to remove this stupid dampening mechanic. Warrior has 0 reason to be dealing 20% less damage. A lot of these perceived problems would vanish instantly if dampening was removed. Yes, a warrior can't kill a holy/prot paladin, and the reason is because the warrior has a stupid 20% damage reduction for no reason. Equal dampening across board heavily favors healing and I can illustrate this with one very simple example:

Scenario 1: No dampening

Player A has 1000 HP, Player B hits Player A for 1000 damage, Player A dies before they can receive any healing. It doesn't matter that holy paladin can heal for 1000 if player A is dead.

Scenario 2: Current dampening

Player A has 1000 HP, Player B hits player A for 800 damage. The paladin heals that person for 800 and the person is back to full HP.

You can see how having equal dampening on both damage dealt and healing done heavily favors the healer. This is why you can't kill paladins, because the dampening screws over anyone that isn't a healer.

Seal of Wisdom or Judgement of Wisdom shouldn't be nerfed because that would be a noticeable nerf to paladins in PvE. If you look at holy paladin in PvE, they are actually the 3rd best healer out of 4. So whatever nerf one proposes should strictly target PvP and not PvE.
+5 / -0

Reilly0
Posts: 14
Forum Reputation: +1 / -0

Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Post#14 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:02 pm

Rtas wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:46 pm The way I see it is that some classes should just crumple against others. effectively making them tough to counter. I'd argue Shaman is actually the Horde's "hard counter" to Paladin. the problem is Turtle did kinda gimp Shaman, if their purge CD was reduced it'd probably make fighting them in BGs less of a pain. even making it like 5 secs or maybe just 3 (dunno if it HAD a cooldown originally).

Paladins are a bitch to fight, especially as a hunter. the ranged stun lets them close the gap, then (is it jdugement?) lets them stun you a 2nd time once they're in range. couple that with their blessing of freedom giving a middle finger to frost and conc shot. yeah

I also think Paladin is probably the EASIER class to play because of the toolset. you have so many means of recovering from bad situations.

I think Pallies need a toning down, but I just don't know where to start really. I'm no expert at the class and I think someone on "the inside" should be looking at the class and see what could be done to fix it, without gimping paladin into uselessness in both PvP and PvE
Reilly0 wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:05 pm
hunters with viper sting are another.
Having fought your kind, gonna say it's fairly common to see you guys just dispell it. even at my lowest rank, it costs me more I think to pop viper than it does for you to dispell it. I swear there's an addon that basically does it FOR YOU (paladins, not you specifically) before the sting even gets a tick off. Also that blessing of freedom basically fucks up the entire idea of using slows on you guys.
Yeah, viper string can be dispelled. I'm not really talking about 1v1s tho, if im in a team fight and have to dispel a viper string, that means I can't heal for a few seconds, at the right moment that could mean deaths. A hpala is only as strong as their team, since they can't kill anything by themselves for the most part. Viper sting is good when its a big team fight, I don't have the time to dispel it, and have to let it sit. It drains quite a bit of mana, moreso than a warlock does.

Oh and, I believe the 2nd stun you're talking about is Repentance. All paladins have HoJ, iirc the range is 10yards. Repentance has a larger range but is only available by going deep into the ret tree, so you won't see any holy paladins that have it
+1 / -1

Pharaoh
Posts: 4
Forum Reputation: +0 / -0

Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Post#15 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:36 pm

Holy resistance gear doesn't exist
Attachments
resistd.png
resistd.png (13.64 KiB) Viewed 24424 times
+5 / -1

Nandieb
Posts: 63
Forum Reputation: +1 / -0

Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Post#16 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:00 pm

I tell you where to start:
Make a list of the 4-5 most desireable traits (mana efficiency, escape tools, damage mitigation, effectiveness of dispels, cc or offensive support tools) of healers in PvP and then rank the 4 healing classes in each of the categories.
In a perfect world, every class would be top in one of the categories, but in our world, paladins tops all.
+4 / -0

Reilly0
Posts: 14
Forum Reputation: +1 / -0

Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Post#17 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:13 pm

This game is largely balanced for PvE, any PvP balancing can't negatively impact PvE, turtle fucked up on this a lot for many classes.
+6 / -0

Dzielkus
Posts: 257
Forum Reputation: +5 / -7

Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Post#18 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:34 pm

Reilly0 wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:13 pm This game is largely balanced for PvE, any PvP balancing can't negatively impact PvE, turtle fucked up on this a lot for many classes.
Retri tops dps, holy tops healing in most of PvE content. While prot doesn't look like weakest tank in roster.

It's subjective, but i don't see any balance in PvE either.
+3 / -1

Reilly0
Posts: 14
Forum Reputation: +1 / -0

Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Post#19 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:48 pm

Dzielkus wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:34 pm
Reilly0 wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:13 pm This game is largely balanced for PvE, any PvP balancing can't negatively impact PvE, turtle fucked up on this a lot for many classes.
Retri tops dps, holy tops healing in most of PvE content. While prot doesn't look like weakest tank in roster.

It's subjective, but i don't see any balance in PvE either.
I'm sorry to say, but that just isn't correct right now. Speaking of holy, its outclassed by priests and druids right now. Holy paladins don't have the output of a priest PoH or a Druid tranq (I'm speaking as one of the top performing holy paladins atm)

Ret is a great dps spec, 2nd overall: https://octo.chronicleclassic.com/leade ... ty=&size=0. They'll fall off slighty the later into phases we get, but they benefit strongly from having a lot of great gear available early.

Picking a weakest tank is not really possible atm, all tanks are equally balanced. Prots are probably the squishest tank, which will be more noticeable in AQ40/Naxx. Bears got nerfed slightly towards the end of turtle which decreased their tps. There's a case for each tank to say they are the best, but I don't think saying "Prot isn't the weakest tank" is a way to discredit the paladin class as a whole.
+3 / -0

Dzielkus
Posts: 257
Forum Reputation: +5 / -7

Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP

Post#20 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:51 pm

Reilly0 wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:48 pm
Dzielkus wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:34 pm
Reilly0 wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:13 pm This game is largely balanced for PvE, any PvP balancing can't negatively impact PvE, turtle fucked up on this a lot for many classes.
Retri tops dps, holy tops healing in most of PvE content. While prot doesn't look like weakest tank in roster.

It's subjective, but i don't see any balance in PvE either.
I'm sorry to say, but that just isn't correct right now. Speaking of holy, its outclassed by priests and druids right now. Holy paladins don't have the output of a priest PoH or a Druid tranq (I'm speaking as one of the top performing holy paladins atm)

Ret is a great dps spec, 2nd overall: https://octo.chronicleclassic.com/leade ... ty=&size=0. They'll fall off slighty the later into phases we get, but they benefit strongly from having a lot of great gear available early.

Picking a weakest tank is not really possible atm, all tanks are equally balanced. Prots are probably the squishest tank, which will be more noticeable in AQ40/Naxx. Bears got nerfed slightly towards the end of turtle which decreased their tps. There's a case for each tank to say they are the best, but I don't think saying "Prot isn't the weakest tank" is a way to discredit the paladin class as a whole.
You picked BWL as filter - in Ony top heal, quite far ahead of priest/druid, is hpala. Shaman is bottom rock on the other hand.

Everything depend on the content ofc, but i think we all have glimpse of idea, which class is most op for ALL content.
Last edited by Dzielkus on Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.
+3 / -0

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest