The ban appeal section is a phenomenal read.

Open discussion about OctoWow.
User avatar
Rathotdog
Posts: 100
Forum Reputation: +3 / -1

Re: The ban appeal section is a phenomenal read.

Post#11 » Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:35 pm

Joeblack wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 1:22 pm and would happen in Raven, if it wasn't completely dead
Oh there were gold sellers on Epoch when Ascension was already publicly shutting down and the server was on borrowed time. And people did buy.

So you can bet Ravencrap is seeing a lot of gold selling.

--

The Ban Appeal section is a wonderful window into the mind of your average swiper, it's almost fascinating.
+2 / -0

Wubc
Posts: 88
Forum Reputation: +5 / -0

Re: The ban appeal section is a phenomenal read.

Post#12 » Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:37 pm

Rathotdog wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:35 pm
The Ban Appeal section is a wonderful window into the mind of your average swiper, it's almost fascinating.
It is also worth noting how high a percentage of the appeals are done in bad faith with clear knowledge of the wrong doing once faced with the evidence. There are remarkably few cases, although they do still exist, where the action taken was either completely incorrect or disproportionate. The admins are batting like a 0.98 average which I think deserves some recognition.
+2 / -0

Saintjenkins
Posts: 2
Forum Reputation: +0 / -3

Re: The ban appeal section is a phenomenal read.

Post#13 » Thu Nov 19, 2026 11:16 pm

Dzielkus wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 1:36 pm I wonder, why ppl are taking such shortcuts if we had so many banned before.
And some had been doing it over and over again
Why?
Because they can and don't care? RMT'rs have money. The appeals that you see are only like the top 3%, the average rmt'er just contacts his favorite booster or provider and orders a new character, done. Or goes to a less zealous server. To put things into perspective, you can buy a decently geared 60 on octo for about 50-150 dollars and jump straight into raiding or pvp. Some people simply prefer pvp'ing and raiding, that's it. Not leveling another character again for the 50th time.

Kestrel is doing a good job, but not nearly as good as you think, he misses plenty.
If you check gold pricing and character pricing for this server it's extremely cheap... means there is plenty of supply, but probably also less demand, I suppose that is good?
The people who get caught are either the ones who don't care or the ones who are stupid and order gold through the mail or trading or don't go through the proper protocols to reduce detection.
Secondly, this server makes it very easy for gold sellers to make money, with vampirism and LBRS, Strat ud aoe farms.... (they should really do something about it, the fact that they haven't caught on to that is laughable)

Between 30-40% of people were rmting on Twow, nobody noticed, nobody cared, because they had an obvious understanding.
This server decided on another way, let's hope it doesn't bite it in the ass, I wouldn't be surprised that this zealous behavior was also the reason for the ddos attacks.
+1 / -1

User avatar
Rathotdog
Posts: 100
Forum Reputation: +3 / -1

Re: The ban appeal section is a phenomenal read.

Post#14 » Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:35 am

Saintjenkins wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 11:16 pm Between 30-40% of people were rmting on Twow, nobody noticed, nobody cared, because they had an obvious understanding.
This server decided on another way, let's hope it doesn't bite it in the ass, I wouldn't be surprised that this zealous behavior was also the reason for the ddos attacks.
The thing is, if they swipe on RMT gold and boosts, they are also more likely to swipe in the donation shop.

Banning these people directly means reducing the revenue the server receives. And then of course, if they swipe on RMT and Donations, they are also likely to swipe on ordering a DDOS as a revenge.

The more gold buyers they ban, the more donations should the normal people buy to offset it. Or as a thank you for keeping the server clean.
+1 / -0

Saintjenkins
Posts: 2
Forum Reputation: +0 / -3

Re: The ban appeal section is a phenomenal read.

Post#15 » Sat Nov 21, 2026 12:30 am

Rathotdog wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:35 am
Saintjenkins wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 11:16 pm Between 30-40% of people were rmting on Twow, nobody noticed, nobody cared, because they had an obvious understanding.
This server decided on another way, let's hope it doesn't bite it in the ass, I wouldn't be surprised that this zealous behavior was also the reason for the ddos attacks.
The thing is, if they swipe on RMT gold and boosts, they are also more likely to swipe in the donation shop.

Banning these people directly means reducing the revenue the server receives. And then of course, if they swipe on RMT and Donations, they are also likely to swipe on ordering a DDOS as a revenge.

The more gold buyers they ban, the more donations should the normal people buy to offset it. Or as a thank you for keeping the server clean.
Jup, that is correct. One of the reasons Twow was so rich. Plenty of RMT people swiping on the shop and the Twow staff didn't do shit because of obvious reasons. They got their money and the RMT guys didn't get banned. Win win

They also had no reason to do anything because the RMT on Twow didn't hurt the economy.
You have two types of RMT operations:
• A: Bots running around—something that nobody likes, the kind you see on retail servers. This creates a high supply and low-cost gold.
• B: Actual people grinding the gold who get paid for it, or passive gold coming from boosters. This creates a lower supply and higher gold cost, but it also has very little effect on the server economy (Twow).

Now, before people start arguing with me about "YeS It DoEs hUrt the server EcoNOmy," sure—to a very minor extent. But so do unbalanced gold farms caused by unbalanced classes and vampirism. Cough cough, vampirism paladins using Force Reactive Disk. You want to control RMT? Easy. Instead of going around playing whack-a-mole with every RMT provider and buyer(turning your server into a big target), balance your server's gold/hour grinds, actively limiting RMTers.
I wouldn't even be surprised if Twow put vampirism in the game just to help RMT and make more money, because vampirism serves NO gameplay purpose other than that—at least that I can see.

The fact that they STILL haven't done that, shows me that all these bans are emotionally driven and equally have no rational thinking behind them.
+1 / -1

Crimsonc
Posts: 6
Forum Reputation: +0 / -0

Re: The ban appeal section is a phenomenal read.

Post#16 » Sat Nov 21, 2026 3:03 pm

The pro-RMT fellas here have had their say, here's mine.

Farmer classes have always been a part of WoW, suggesting they cause RMT because they make farming too easy and so it's Octo's fault is not a sustainable argument. Certainly not seeing any receipts for this claim - as it stands it's no more than an insinuation. People who want to make money through WoW would farm on prot warriors if that was the only option. Vamp, prot pallies, aoe shamans - they might be easier to farm with but not to the point of triviality. People who RMT for gold and rare mats hurt the economy considerably, the randomly jacket up AH prices on a young server are neither typical nor healthy. Fortunately they're rare because Octo bans em.

The number of people in world chat who celebrate cheaters of any kind getting banned shows it's a hugely popular measure, with the dissenters being... two posters on the dinosaur forum. RMTers being a huge minority of the player base is simply not credible. The claim that they donate more also comes down to Trust Me Bro. Again, no receipts. Someone saying something sometime on discord 5yrs ago doesn't count.

Finally, the commentary about Octo getting ddossed by a possibly vengeful RMT broker because Octo admins are "too zealous" smacks of the kind of people who would blame a store for getting vandalized because it threw out shoplifters and rowdy customers. It's just not a legit argument.

Honestly the entire pro-RMT side just seems to be Trust Me Bro and comes off like the kind of reassurances multnational conglomerate corportations give when they tell you they aren't polluting local rivers THAT much, and all those mom-and-pop businesses they drove out were dying anyway.
+1 / -0

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Aliaah, Mrsneed and 1 guest