2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00
2026-09-20 19:03:27 +01:00

Equip Compare Adv

Gear comparison for Turtle WoW, Octo WoW, Ravencraft and other 1.12.1 servers. Hover any item you could equip and a panel next to the tooltip tells you:

  • What you have equipped in that slot, by name, with its score.
  • Every stat you'd gain and lose, green and red, with how many score points each one is worth.
  • A score for both items, worked out for your class and spec.
  • A verdict: big upgrade, upgrade, sidegrade, downgrade or big downgrade, and whether equipping it is recommended.
  • Who the item is made for: tank, DPS or healer, the classes and specs that get the most out of it, and how well it fits your own spec.

It also warns you about the things a score can't see: a set bonus you'd break, a Use or proc effect you'd lose, an item you can't equip yet.

The game's own tooltips are never changed, so it works alongside other tooltip addons.

Quick start

  1. Download the zip from the latest release. Copy the EquipCompareAdv folder inside it into Interface\AddOns\ in your game folder, then fully restart the game. Full install steps.
  2. Hover an item in your bags, at a vendor, in the loot window, on the auction house or in a chat link.
  3. Hold Alt for the detailed view.
  4. Type /eca for the options window.

Found a bug? See Reporting bugs.

Install

With an addon launcher (the Turtle WoW launcher, RavenLaunch and similar): paste this repo's address, https://github.com/notforever-ship-it/EquipCompareAdv, into its GitHub addon installer. The addon files sit at the top level of the repo, which is the layout launchers expect.

By hand:

  1. Download the zip from the latest release. It contains a ready-made EquipCompareAdv folder. (If you use Code → Download ZIP instead, the folder inside is called EquipCompareAdv-master; rename it to EquipCompareAdv or the game won't load it.)
  2. Copy that folder into World of Warcraft\Interface\AddOns\. The path should end in Interface\AddOns\EquipCompareAdv\EquipCompareAdv.toc.
  3. Fully restart the game. /reload doesn't pick up newly added addons.
  4. On the character select screen, click AddOns and make sure Equip Compare Adv is ticked.

What the panel shows

Equip Compare Adv                          Fury

Equipped - Head
Helm of Might                        score 47.1
  Enchant: +8 Stamina
This item                           score 165.7
If you swap:
  +3 Strength                                +6
  -43 Stamina                              -8.6
  +2% Crit Chance                           +64
  +2% Hit Chance                            +60
  -7 Defense                               -1.4
>> BIG UPGRADE  +118.6 (+251.8%)
Recommended: equip it.
Biggest gain                    +2% Crit Chance
Biggest loss                        -43 Stamina
Careful: your Head is part of Battlegear of Might (3/8 worn)...

Made for:                           DPS (melee)
Best for:                     Warrior Arms 100%
                        Paladin Retribution 98%
Fit for your spec:                         100%
  • Rings, trinkets and one-handed weapons are compared with both slots, and the panel says which one to swap.
  • Two-handers are compared with your main hand and off hand together. An off-hand weapon's damage counts half, as it does in game.
  • Hovering something you're wearing shows its score and your total gear score instead.
  • The character window shows your total gear score under your character.

Verdicts

Verdict Meaning
BIG UPGRADE 15% or more better than what you have. Equip it.
UPGRADE 3% to 15% better. Equip it.
SIDEGRADE Within 3%. Pick the stats you like more.
DOWNGRADE / BIG DOWNGRADE Worse. Keep what you have.
BETTER THAN NOTHING The slot is empty, but the item's stats do little for your spec.

Detail levels

Level Shows
Compact Both scores, the verdict and the recommendation.
Normal Plus every stat change, warnings and who the item is made for.
Detailed Plus before and after numbers, unchanged stats, what the change does in practice (attack power, crit, health...), the effect on your total gear score, and where you stand on hit caps.

Holding Alt shows Detailed at any time.

How the score works

Every spec has a weight for the stats that do the work: attack power, crit, hit, spell damage, healing, health, armor and so on. Strength, Agility, Stamina, Intellect and Spirit are worth what they turn into for your class, using the 1.12 conversion rates:

  • A warrior's Strength is 2 attack power; a rogue's is 1.
  • Agility is crit and dodge for everyone, attack power for rogues, hunters and cat druids, and 2 ranged attack power for hunters. It takes 20 Agility for 1% crit on a warrior, 29 on a rogue, 53 on a hunter.
  • Intellect is 15 mana and spell crit (about 60 Intellect for 1%).
  • Spirit is mana regeneration, counted for the share of a fight it really works in.

The conversions scale with your level, so crit from Agility is worth more on a level 30 than on a level 60.

Melee and hunter scores count in attack power, caster scores in spell damage, healer scores in healing and tank scores in stamina. A score only means something next to another score for the same spec.

Specs: Arms, Fury, Protection · Holy, Protection, Retribution · Hunter · Rogue · Holy/Discipline, Shadow · Elemental, Enhancement, Restoration · Arcane, Fire, Frost · Shadow and Fire warlock · Balance, Cat, Bear, Restoration. Auto follows your talents: the tree with the most points picks the spec. Feral druids get Cat; pick Bear by hand when you tank.

Hit caps. Hit stops helping once you can't miss. The addon adds up the hit on the rest of your gear and the hit talents you've taken (Precision, Surefooted, Nature's Guidance, Elemental Precision, Arcane Focus, Shadow Focus, Suppression), and only counts the part of an item's hit that still does something. Past the cap, hit keeps half its value if you dual wield and none otherwise. Caps are 9% melee and ranged and 16% spell against raid bosses, 5% and 3% against things your own level; Auto uses the raid numbers at level 60. Tanks in raid mode also value defense less past 440.

Leveling casters get a weight for wand damage that fades to nothing by level 60.

Enchants on your gear are counted by default, so you see what really changes the moment you swap. Tick Ignore enchants to compare bare items instead.

Not in the score: set bonuses, Use effects, procs and other special effects. The panel lists them so you can judge them yourself.

"Made for"

The addon looks at how an item's stat budget is spent and checks it against every spec of every class that can equip it (armor type, weapon skills, class restrictions). The spec that wastes the least of the budget is who the item is made for. Stamina is on nearly everything, so it only counts towards tanks.

Options

/eca opens the options window:

  • Score items for: Auto, or any spec of your class.
  • Switches for the comparison, Shift-only mode, score points, the "made for" lines, the character window score and ignoring enchants.
  • Detail and Hit caps buttons.
  • Stat weights: a window listing what every stat is worth to your spec. Type a new number and press Enter to change it; changed stats turn gold. Strength and the other primary stats show what they're worth on the right, and a number typed there is added on top. Your changes are saved per character and per spec. You can also tell the addon about hit you get from somewhere it can't see.
  • List my gear: everything you have equipped, with scores, in chat.

Commands

Command What it does
/eca Open the options window
/eca on · /eca off Switch the comparison on or off
/eca spec auto · /eca spec fury What to score for
/eca detail 1 · 2 · 3 Compact, normal or detailed
/eca shift Only show while Shift is held
/eca caps auto · raid · leveling · off How hit caps are judged
/eca enchants Count or ignore enchants
/eca gear List your equipped gear with scores
/eca weights List the stat weights
/eca weight CRIT 30 Change one weight; /eca weight reset puts them back
/eca hit 3 · /eca spellhit 2 Extra hit % from buffs or talents the addon can't see
/eca help List the commands in game

Good to know

  • The 1.12 client doesn't tell addons what stats an item has, so the addon reads the tooltip text. It needs the English client.
  • Stat weights are a starting point, not gospel. They're tuned for level 60 PvE; if your guild or a class guide uses different numbers, type them into the Stat weights window.
  • Servers with custom talents can change what a stat is worth. If a verdict looks wrong for your server, adjust the weight and it stays adjusted.

Reporting bugs

Open an issue and include:

  • The item you hovered and what you had equipped.
  • Your class, level and the spec shown at the top of the panel.
  • What the panel said and what you expected.
  • If a red error appeared in chat, type /eca debug and copy the line it prints.

For developers

  • The addon files live at the repo root, which is the layout launchers expect; tools/ is development only and left out of release zips.
  • node tools/check-lua.js parses every file as Lua 5.0 and flags things the 1.12 client doesn't have.
  • node tools/install.js [path to Interface\AddOns] copies the addon into a game folder.
  • Stats.lua reads tooltips, Profiles.lua holds the spec weights and the "made for" judgement, Compare.lua scores and compares, Panel.lua draws.

Credits

Made by stealthzi.

License

MIT. See LICENSE.

S
Description
Gear comparison for the 1.12 client (Turtle WoW, Octo WoW): stat gains and losses, a score for your spec, a verdict, and who each item is made for
Readme MIT
116 KiB
Languages
Lua 86%
JavaScript 14%