Page 3 of 9
Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:53 pm
by Reilly0
Dzielkus wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:51 pm
Reilly0 wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:48 pm
Dzielkus wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:34 pm
Retri tops dps, holy tops healing in most of PvE content. While prot doesn't look like weakest tank in roster.
It's subjective, but i don't see any balance in PvE either.
I'm sorry to say, but that just isn't correct right now. Speaking of holy, its outclassed by priests and druids right now. Holy paladins don't have the output of a priest PoH or a Druid tranq (I'm speaking as one of the top performing holy paladins atm)
Ret is a great dps spec, 2nd overall:
https://octo.chronicleclassic.com/leade ... ty=&size=0. They'll fall off slighty the later into phases we get, but they benefit strongly from having a lot of great gear available early.
Picking a weakest tank is not really possible atm, all tanks are equally balanced. Prots are probably the squishest tank, which will be more noticeable in AQ40/Naxx. Bears got nerfed slightly towards the end of turtle which decreased their tps. There's a case for each tank to say they are the best, but I don't think saying "Prot isn't the weakest tank" is a way to discredit the paladin class as a whole.
You picked BWL as filter - in Ony top heal, quite far ahead of priest/druid, is hpala.
Yes, I picked the latest raid tier as the benchmark to see how each class is performing.
Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:19 pm
by Rocksmash
They need to buff warriors, specifically Pummel, and Prot
Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 11:08 pm
by Svarrog
Hey everone.
Another certified paladin enjoyer here, playing all specs since cc1 on turtle.
I am PVE player, I've never liked PvP in this WoW version in any balance iteration. For me it felt like rock-paper-scissors: certain classes hard-counter some, while getting countered by others. Anyway I have some ret/holy PvP experience.
I agree that paladins, especially holy paladins are now too strong in PvP, but I disagree with your suggested changes, because they will affect PvE greatly.
Your first suggested change about wisdom procs kills prot and ret PvE gameplay, I play mostly prot and mana gain feels confortable only with at least one on-hit item equiped
"Nerf blessed strike" - paladin healer is already far from top1 healer according to logs.
It is icredably hard to balance both PvE and PvP, dampening was logical solution, problem is turtle did it very clumsily. So imo this is the first thing to be removed or, perfectly, changed.
P.S. We all know know this paladin meta hate lasts forever, and I want you to remember one thing. Which fraction had bigger winrate in battlegrounds before cross fraction was added? Do you think all those "overpowered" paladins in bubble won games? Horde won much more games that time. And it was before damage while bubbled, blessing of sacrifce CC escape were nerfed.
Still I think holy paladins need some type of nerf in pvp. But need to be careful not to touch pve doing it.
Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:10 am
by Eemo
I am PVE player, I've never liked PvP in this WoW version in any balance iteration. For me it felt like rock-paper-scissors: certain classes hard-counter some, while getting countered by others. Anyway I have some ret/holy PvP experience.
Yes, I agree with classic pvp is about rock-paper-scissor, but right now this scissor is too freaking big it breaks the rock.
Your first suggested change about wisdom procs kills prot and ret PvE gameplay, I play mostly prot and mana gain feels confortable only with at least one on-hit item equiped
I also played paladin tank on Ambershire for my guild <Who did it> as an offtank, and I had never feel like I don't have enough mana as an offtank. Ofc I put my assigned judgment, I buff blessings, I help dispel.
What I'm suggesting here is to move some of the mana gain from the seals/judgements to blocking, which should provide enough mana for you if you're tanking & blocking.
Nerf blessed strike - paladin healer is already far from top1 healer according to logs.
I suggest you go check out <Skull Emoji>'s recent MC and BWL logs and you'd be surprised to see how Hpal are above other healers. I also noticed a lot of hpal players do not play this spec to its full potential - meaning you are not casting holy strike as often as it should be, instead you rely too much on flash of light.
It is without a doubt that Hpal is also the strongest healer in PvE.
Also, I am suggesting a nerf to blessed strike specifically towards the holy shock <=> crusader strike interaction. Therefore, it shouldn't affect your PvE experience as you had imagined.
Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:48 am
by Reilly0
I find it a little funny that you're arguing with people who play holy paladin in PvE, and telling them that they are the best PvE healer, when that's factually false. Priests and druids dominate the logs, and even in the guild you mentioned, a shaman and druid are above the paladins. One of which is Praylorswift, I raided with him, and im sure he'd tell you the exact same thing I'm saying.
Removal of dampening is probably the way forward here
Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:20 am
by Eemo
Reilly0 wrote: Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:48 am
I find it a little funny that you're arguing with people who play holy paladin in PvE, and telling them that they are the best PvE healer, when that's factually false. Priests and druids dominate the logs, and even in the guild you mentioned, a shaman and druid are above the paladins. One of which is Praylorswift, I raided with him, and im sure he'd tell you the exact same thing I'm saying.
Removal of dampening is probably the way forward here
Please check the logs and not just the overall healing.
https://octo.chronicleclassic.com/insta ... JIY--TXcbU
https://octo.chronicleclassic.com/insta ... vaZggAxEPw
https://octo.chronicleclassic.com/insta ... SR7OeH6UvT
I wish I could provide you the logs from my previous guild on Ambershire <who did it> or logs from <Hard Knocks Society>, sadly those turtlogs have been wiped. Hpal being the strongest among all is pure factual because they don't need to drink and they heal with holy strike (smart heal) and flash of light (1.5s good for snipes).
Ofc, if your raid allows healer to drink all the time, meaning priest/druid does not have issues with mana, sure I can see them also being competitive.
Also may I ask which part of the suggestion threw you off? because I specifically say adjust the interaction between holy shock and crusader strike. That's not your main healing spell in raid. What's the concern?
Furthermore, are you aware of the fact that you can still properly burst people very fast in the current stage of game?
Because suggesting a removal of dampening is not very considerate imo. Almost feel like you are not familiar with how PvP works at the moment.
Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:31 am
by Reilly0
Why are you telling me to look at those logs? The only logs that prove your point are the Onyxia ones. Literally look at the healing rankings that rank based on effective healing, I don't know if I can make it any simpler for you.
My main concern is that you don't understand the class. Holy strike is not a smart heal, not in the way chain heal used to be for shamans, educate yourself on the current PvE meta before proposing changes that would nerf the class in PvE.
Lastly, I never mentioned a removal of dampening entirely, it should differ between classes. A flat percentage to all isn't helping anybody atm.
Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:34 am
by Zumitpo2
Well said, feel this very much. Not much to add, you covered all of it I think, couldn't agree with Eemo's well thought out post more.
Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:43 am
by Eemo
Reilly0 wrote: Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:31 am
Why are you telling me to look at those logs? The only logs that prove your point are the Onyxia ones. Literally look at the healing rankings that rank based on effective healing, I don't know if I can make it any simpler for you.
My main concern is that you don't understand the class. Holy strike is not a smart heal, not in the way chain heal used to be for shamans, educate yourself on the current PvE meta before proposing changes that would nerf the class in PvE.
Lastly, I never mentioned a removal of dampening entirely, it should differ between classes. A flat percentage to all isn't helping anybody atm.
I still don't understand how's "adjust interaction between crusader strike and holy shock" is gonna "nerf the class in PvE". But thank you for your input. Also my apologies on my poor word choise, holy shock isn't entirely a smart heal, but it is a healing spell that heals 5 targets around you that gives you mana back, fair enough?
Oh, if you have any logs that can support what you said, I'd love to check them out. Thanks !
Re: Let's have a chat about paladins in PvP
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:51 am
by Reilly0
I think we can all see what's going on here. 3 paladins came in here in good faith to discuss the issues with the class. I think I could show you proof that the sky is blue, and you still wouldn't believe it. Agendas will be agendas
